Quest for Productivity Leads to Nakamura
Based just outside Dundee, Quest Precision Engineering Ltd has been on a trajectory of continuous growth. The Scottish manufacturer initially acquired two Nakamura-Tome turning centres through the pandemic and it has just added another two of the industry-leading turning centres to the plant list.
Now with four Nakamura-Tome WT150II turning centres from Engineering Technology Group’s (ETG) Scottish distribution partner RAM Engineering & Tooling, the 20,000sq/ft facility is filling fast with the industry’s leading multitasking machine tools. Serving customers in the oil & gas, electronics, automotive and aerospace industries, ISO9001:2015 certified Quest Precision is well versed in machining everything from simple to the most complex of components. It is this requirement for one-hit machining of complex parts from challenging materials that led to the installation of the first Nakamura-Tome turning centre in December 2019, a twin-spindle twin turret WT150II. The impact of the Nakamura-Tome WT150II resulted in a second machine being installed four months later and this has now been followed by two more machines that were delivered at the end of July.
Before Quest installed its first Nakamura-Tome WT150II, it was machining autonomous valves for the oil and gas industry in five operations on four machine tools. The production of the complex 2-inch diameter Inconel 718 valves that control the flow of oil from wells was time-consuming and not cost-effective enough to compete with an existing Chinese supplier. To win more of the business from the overseas supplier, Quest needed to increase productivity and reduce costs – the answer was the Nakamura-Tome WT150II.
Discussing the situation, Quest Precision’s Managing Director, Mr Gordon Deuchars says: “There are 25-30 different valves in the family of parts and for us to win more business, we had to increase throughput and reduce costs to be cost-competitive with China. Ross Milne from RAM Engineering & Tooling discussed the merits of a Nakamura turnkey solution for the valves and our decision was made. It has been such a success; the first two machines made a huge impact and brought us significantly more business. To support the subsequent growth and do more R&D work, we bought the next two machines.”
Depending upon the valve variant, the majority of valves were processed in 2-4 hours on four machine tools with an additional 25% set-up time across the numerous machines. Running everything from prototypes right through to production runs of 1000-off, producing such volumes on the existing machine tools was unfeasible. The first twin-turret twin-spindle Nakamura-Tome WT150II immediately alleviated the situation, the second machine solved it and machines 3 and 4 are helping the company cope with its influx of new orders.
One hit machining on the WT150II initially reduced cycle times by 50% to 1.5 hours whilst freeing capacity and labour requirements throughout the shop floor. As Gordon recalls: “The WT150II made such a difference to our production and set-ups that we ordered a second machine within weeks. Instead of using multiple machines and up to five staff on the valves, we have one operator running the two Nakamura’s. With one staff member running the machines on days and another on nights, the first two WT150II machines increased our productivity by 500%, making us cost-competitive with China. They also reduced our tooling costs considerably due to the machine set-up and rigidity. The latest two machines have immediately mirrored the success of the first two.”
The result of investing in the first two Nakamura machines significantly increased business from this particular offshore customer – and this is why two more WT150II machines have followed. As Gordon recalls: “The challenge this offshore customer had with supply from China was proximity. Proximity made any R&D work, amendments or part inspection an issue. Now, they can visit our facility to discuss projects, look at our production methods and equipment and investigate opportunities to enhance and develop their product lines with a local supplier and that is exactly what they are doing.”
“We started production on what they called the Mach 1, 2 and 3 valve designs. Now, we are fully integrated into the customers’ R&D infrastructure, and we are working closely with them on the development of the Mach 4 valve. Since investing in the Nakamura machines, we have won much more business from this customer and the Nakamura’s are 95% dedicated to producing and undertaking R&D work on the inconel valves.”
Looking specifically at the latest two WT150II machines, Gordon says: “The latest machines have upgraded software, which has since been loaded to the previous two machines. The software incorporates tool monitoring and tool wear notifications to ensure we maintain optimal cutting conditions and have no tooling failures. Additionally, the software has a new optimisation feature. With the touch of a button, the software will review a programme and automatically make incremental improvements to tool path movements and reduce turret movements for tool changes. This has instantly shaved more than 30 seconds from some programmes.”
In conclusion, Gordon says: “The first two WT150II machines improved and streamlined productivity, reduced costs and enabled us to better allocate our staff, freeing more than 15% of capacity from the rest of our facility. Evidently, the result of the initial investment won us a lot more work and this justified the purchase of the second two WT150II machines. Our next step will be to install the Amorphous Core Transformers (ACT) from ETG on the two newest Nakamura’s. This will reduce our power consumption by more than 15%. Once installed, we can compare the financial and environmental benefits of the latest machines with their predecessors. We are committed to improving our carbon footprint and environmental credentials whilst running our business as efficiently as possible, the ACT from ETG will help us to fulfil these ambitions.” concludes Gordon.